Prospective roundtable presenter: Marcelo Gleiser

We may consider inviting Professor Gleiser to our a future roundtable event. He’s already spoken at roundtable events at Dartmouth and Amherst College with great success and outstanding reviews. Below is a recent article he wrote.

— Marcelo Gleiser is a theoretical physicist and cosmologist, and professor of natural philosophy, physics and astronomy at Dartmouth College.  He is co-founder of the NPR science blog 13.7, a prolific author of papers and essays, and active promoter of science to the general public.  His latest book is The Island of Knowledge: The Limits of Science and the Search for Meaning.


The Equation That Blew Up The Cosmos

by Marcelo Gleiser
November 25, 2015
Albert Einstein postage stamp.

On this very day 100 years ago, while Europe was buried deep in the darkness of the Great War, Albert Einstein wrote down the equation that changed forever the way we understand space, time and matter.

To a large extent, the equation also changed the way we understand ourselves, as suddenly, from its folded mathematical convolutions, the universe itself became a dynamic, evolving entity, endowed with a history.  Within this history, the birth and death of stars, and the creation of the chemical elements and their gathering into complex compounds in nascent planets, became a persistent feature.  Life unfolded here, as it could have elsewhere, as part of this grand cosmic drama of which we are integral players.  Big Bang, black holes, warped spacetime, wormholes, time machines, even our GPS devices all depend in some way on Einstein’s remarkable creation, a new way to describe gravity.

I can’t resist writing the equation down:  

      Rmn – ½ gmnR = 8pG Tmn  

The reader no doubt recognizes the equal sign that separates the two sides.  The arcane-looking symbols on the left describe the geometry of space and the flow of time; the Tmn on the right describes how energy and matter are distributed in space, whether moving or not.  (G is the gravitational constant that already appeared in Newton’s theory of gravity from 1686.)  In other words, the equation relates the geometry of space and the flow of time — now malleable quantities, amenable to distortions — to the distribution of matter in space.  As the great physicist John Archibald Wheeler once wrote, matter tells space how to curve and space tells matter how to move.  This is the essence of Einstein’s theory of general relativity, a theory that many physicists consider the most beautiful ever conceived.

Einstein was convinced his theory was correct even before it was tested.  A journalist asked him what he would do if the theory was wrong.  His reply became famous: “Then I would feel sorry for the good Lord.  The theory is correct.”

Fortunately for the good Lord and for Einstein, the theory is correct.  Einstein’s amazing predictions from the theory were verified to high accuracy:  light from distant stars is bent as it passes nearby other stars on its way to Earth; time slows down in strong gravitational fields; Mercury’s orbit slowly precesses like a wobbling top due to its proximity to the sun.  In other words, a large gathering of matter (and hence energy due to the E=mc2 formula, another one of Einstein’s creations, this one from 110 years ago) bends the geometry of space and affects the flow of time in measurable ways.

Einstein would no doubt be happy to know that his theory is not complete.  As we celebrate 100 years of general relativity around the world, many questions remain open, questions that would no doubt astound Einstein.

For example, if we apply his theory to the universe, it predicts, as we go back toward the beginning of time, that space contracts to a point with zero volume and infinite energy.  Clearly, such an absurd situation can’t be how the universe began its history.  When an otherwise robust theory displays such “singularities,” we know something is wrong.  What’s wrong here is that we cannot apply Einstein’s theory of gravity very close to the beginning of time, aka the Big Bang.  Something else is needed, presumably a theory that is not afraid to face small distances, such as the quantum theory that describes the behavior of atoms and subatomic particles.  But we still don’t know how to handle this marriage of the quantum and Einstein’s relativity.

In 1998, another cosmic mystery surfaced with the discovery that the universe is not just expanding but it does so at an accelerated clip.  This phase apparently started some 5 billion years ago or so, for reasons that remain obscure.  The amazing thing is that something like 70 percent of the stuff that fills the cosmos is working to feed this cosmic acceleration — and we have no clue what this stuff, called dark energy, is.  Some claim it’s a new field with bizarre properties; others claim Einstein’s theory needs editing and it can’t be the final word.

In the best possible way, Einstein’s beautiful theory leads to beautiful experiments that test its validity — and to beautiful models that try to extend its validity into realms far removed from current experiments.  Newton’s theory inspired magnificent work on celestial dynamics that has been feeding the imagination of physicists and mathematicians for more than 300 years.  We now live under Einstein’s spell, in the bizarre cosmos that emerged from his theory.  We are only beginning to explore all that is hidden within those arcane symbols.

Einstein, who disliked black holes, would be aghast if he knew that practically every galaxy has a giant one in its center.  But he would surely be very pleased with the revolution he started, a source of wonder and inspiration for this generation and many more to come.

Happy centennial birthday, general relativity!

— Marcelo Gleiser is a theoretical physicist and cosmologist, and professor of natural philosophy, physics and astronomy at Dartmouth College.  He is co-founder of the NPR science blog 13.7, a prolific author of papers and essays, and active promoter of science to the general public.  His latest book is The Island of Knowledge: The Limits of Science and the Search for Meaning.

Another great event on Oct. 1st!

RoundtablePanoThank you for everyone’s participation in this lively experiment! Check back here in early 2016 to see when our next event will take place. Feel free to pass along any topic ideas or suggestions for potential presenters.

Register NOW for our next event on Thursday, October 1st

 “The Mystery of Cosmological Constants: Evidence for the Existence of God?”

Our next event will feature Professor Walter Bradley and Dr. Randy Isaac who will be discussing whether or not cosmological constants provide evidence for the existence of God. Professor Bradley says yes, Dr. Isaac says no. Both are long time friends and so their presentations and interactions will make a great start for our dinner discussions.

6:00pm Thursday, October 1 – REGISTER NOW

More info. and speaker bios here. Please see the pre-event readings that will help frame our dinner discussions.

Future roundtables

Thank you to everyone who helped our first year of roundtables a great success! Please check back here this summer for details on our next Providence Roundtable in the coming academic year.

In the meantime, consider checking out where it all started in Boston. On Thursday, May 14th is the next Cambridge Roundtable addressing the topic of “Science and the Modern World?” with Harvard Professor of the History Science, Steven Shapin. Click here to register.

Top 10 reasons to attend a roundtable event

  1. Meet new people.
  2. Make new friends.
  3. Free food.
  4. Begin to collaborate with faculty from different academic departments.
  5. Great discussions on relevant topics.
  6. Enjoy an evening out.
  7. Free drinks (with open bar).
  8. Learn something new.
  9. Hundreds of other faculty in the New England area are doing this (e.g., Harvard, MIT, Dartmouth, Yale)
  10. It’s fun.


What’s the format of the roundtable event?

It’s a fairly simple schedule for the evening. While the official time says 6-9pm, the event is actually more like 6:30-8:30pm. Here’s what happens.

People arrive between 600-6:30pm and enjoy casual conversation while being served various appetizers and grabbing a beverage from the open bar.

At 6:30pm, guests take their seat and their assigned table before hearing from the roundtable coordinator’s opening remarks (5 minutes), followed by the presenters for that evening (usually 2 professors who speak for about 12 minutes each).

About 7:00pm, dinner is served and the table discussions begin.

About 8:00pm, dessert and coffee is served. And then the roundtable coordinator will call everyone’s attention back to the front for a time of live question/answer between the guests and the presenters (~20 minutes).

And around 8:30pm, the roundtable coordinator will close the evening with some brief remarks. People are free to leave or stay to continue chatting with their colleagues.

Good food. Good conversation. And all of it complimentary thanks to, in large part, the Templeton Religion Trust.

Our first event is scheduled!

Save the Date! The Providence Roundtable will have its first dinner event the evening of Tuesday, Oct. 28th at the Brown Faculty Club. Mark your calendars now and be looking for the official invitation in late September. If you would like to ask about joining our invitation our invitation list, please contact us:

In Deo Speramus–In light of modern science, is there still a place for God and religion in the university?”

Featuring two Brown professors as co-presenters: Ken Miller and Mark Cladis. More about this event here.